Service or Quotes:

(419) 884-0095

FAQ Report A Claim

  • How do I report a claim?

Give us a call at 419-884-0095 and one of our agents will discuss and submit your claim to your insurance carrier.  Office Hours are Monday through Friday 8:00am to 12:00pm & 1:00pm to 5:00pm.

  • How do I report a claim after hours?

Erie Insurance:  800-367-3743 Opt. 4

Goodville Mutual Casualty:  800-448-6422

Auto Owners Insurance:  888-252-4626

Pekin Insurance:  888-735-4611

Progressive Insurance:  800-274-4499

Foremost Insurance:  800-527-3907

  • Can I report a claim online?

Erie Insurance:  No online claim report

Goodville Mutual Casualty: “Report a Claim” Tab

Auto Owners:  No online claim report

Pekin Insurance: “File a Claim” Tab

Progressive Insurance: “Report a Claim” Tab

Foremost Insurance: “Claims” Tab

  • What if I have an auto glass claim?

Erie Insurance:  800-552-3743 Opt. 1

Goodville Mutual Casualty:  877-445-5780

Auto Owners Insurance:  888-295-2590

Pekin Insurance:  888-735-4611

  • What if I need road side service?

Erie Insurance:  800-367-3743 Opt. 2

Auto Owners Insurance:  888-869-2642

Pekin Insurance:  888-735-4611

Progressive Insurance:  800-776-2778

  • What If I have a Life Insurance Claim?

Erie Insurance:  800-458-0811 Opt. 3

Auto Owners Insurance:  888-252-4626

Pekin Insurance:  800-371-9622

  • Does my insurance carrier have a mobile app?

Pekin Insurance:  Yes

Progressive Insurance:  Yes

Foremost Insurance:  Yes

Facebook Google+ Yelp

Request a Quote


Blackstone Insurance Agency is simply the best in the business. Blackstone Insurance Agency has turned my personal & commercial insurance headaches into a seamless process, while saving me money & time along the way. At Blackstone you are not just a policy number; you are treated like a friend and feel like family.
Michael S.


2730 Lexington Avenue
Lexington OH 44904
Phone: (419) 884-0095
Fax: (567) 343-2952

Trusted Choice

Ohio Insurance Agents, Inc.

Progressive Drive


Support Our Troops